The Premium Cigar Association's November 3 retail survey says staff recommendations led the strategies shops rated best for increasing average sales. A bonus for steering you toward one box turns that advice into a commission. Owners must kill product spiffs and checkout contests.
A product spiff buys the answer
The trade group's December 1, 2021, holiday guide printed this retailer tip: “Put a spiff on the highest end cigar in your humidor.” It also published another retailer's endorsement of an add-on contest at the register. These are concrete incentive designs worth rejecting.
A spiff is an extra reward attached to a sale. Put it on a particular cigar, and an employee gains a personal financial reason to favor that cigar. The cigar may be excellent. The payout still belongs outside the recommendation.

Imagine asking for something short, woody and restrained on pepper. A useful answer starts with those preferences. A product bonus adds the employee's reward to a decision that should turn on our preferences and budget. We shouldn't need to subtract somebody else's incentive from the answer.
Our cigar flavor vocabulary guide can help us describe the cigar we want. The person across the counter should use that description to narrow the choice. If a shop pays extra for steering us toward a designated box, it has put a commission inside the advice. Kill that payment.
Kill the checkout contest
In the new survey of 125 retail members, 72.8% selected checkout as the location of their best-performing impulse items. Cutters were among the leading revenue-generating add-ons, selected by 32% in a question allowing multiple choices. That makes the counter a consequential place to set staff incentives.
A cutter belongs in a cigar shop. Offering one to a customer who needs it is useful service. Offering it because an add-on contest rewards another sale changes the employee's reason for asking. The shop should remove that reason, then let the customer's answer settle the transaction.

Suppose an adult gift buyer has already chosen the cigars. The employee should ask whether the recipient owns a cutter and has somewhere to keep them. If the answer is yes, the sale can end. A complete purchase doesn't have to become a larger purchase.
An employee who hears that the recipient already owns a good cutter has done the job properly. A contest that counts only add-ons gives that useful answer no credit.
We can use our accessories guide to separate the jobs different tools perform. A shop should do the same at the counter: explain the missing function, offer the appropriate tool, and accept a refusal. Turn the checkout contest off. Leave the cutter available.
The best case against abolishing spiffs
The strongest retailer response is that selling takes skill, and skill should pay. In its September 12, 2025, account of retail work, Tobacconist University describes staff handling plugged cigars, cracked wrappers and leaking lighters. The employee who solves those problems and generates revenue helps keep the doors open. Bonuses can reward that contribution and make the job worth keeping.

There is experimental evidence for the business argument. A German bakery-chain study published in August 2017 covered 193 shops and 1,300 employees. Team bonuses increased sales and customer numbers by 3%. Each bonus dollar generated $2.10 in profit. Owners have a serious reason to reward selling.
Our evidence establishes neither today's prevalence of cigar spiffs nor dishonest advice by any particular seller; the retail-chain result also isn't a forecast for tobacconists.
But a profitable bonus program doesn't justify attaching a payout to a particular cigar. Reward the team for the shop's success. Pay knowledgeable employees more. A product bounty goes further: it rewards choosing the employer's designated item. That is exactly the choice we want the tobacconist to make for us independently.
Owners must end the product bounty
| Evidence | What was reported or rewarded | Our judgment | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Holiday guide, 2021 | A bonus on the highest-end cigar and a checkout add-on contest | Abolish both incentives | PCA holiday guide |
| Retail survey, 2026 | 52% chose staff recommendations as the best strategy for increasing average sales | Protect the recommendation | PCA survey |
| Bakery retail experiment, 2017 | Team bonuses increased sales and customer numbers by 3% | Reward the team without a designated-product bounty | American Economic Review |
A shop owner can start with the compensation sheet. Remove payments tied to designated cigars, and remove prizes for checkout additions. Put that budget into wages, paid training or a team share of profits. Staff should hear that ending a contest isn't an excuse to shrink their compensation.
Pay for an experienced employee to teach a colleague how to inspect a wrapper or explain wrapper, binder and filler. Give that lesson time on the schedule. Product knowledge deserves a wage even when the customer decides to leave the expensive cigar in its box.

Then judge service beyond the size of the basket. Listen for an explanation in the customer's own terms. Notice whether the employee respects the spending limit and diagnoses a storage problem before prescribing another humidor. An owner can observe that work, praise it and make it count when reviewing pay.
The shop still earns a margin when it sells a cigar. We know that. What we want removed is the additional reward for choosing a designated product, because the employee is precisely the person we have asked to help us choose.
Stop asking customers to police your payroll
Shop owners owe customers advice they can trust without an interrogation about payroll. End every bonus tied to a designated cigar and every checkout add-on contest. Customers shouldn't have to ask which answer earns the employee extra money.
We should also bring useful feedback. A tasting notebook gives the next conversation something better than a vague request for whatever is popular. Tell the tobacconist what worked and what didn't. Expect them to listen without a product payout tugging at the answer.
If you own a shop, strike those incentives from the compensation sheet. Keep the money in staff pay and training. Until you do, stop presenting a paid nudge toward one box as independent judgment. Kill the spiffs and checkout contests, and let a tobacconist's recommendation be worth something again.
Sources
- PCA Retail Survey: What's Driving Sales at Premium Cigar Shops in 2026?, Premium Cigar Association, 2026-11-03.
- 2021 Retail Tobacconist Guide to Holiday Readiness, Premium Cigar Association, 2021-12-01.
- Why We Love Tobacconists, Tobacconist University, 2025-09-12.
- Team Incentives and Performance: Evidence from a Retail Chain, American Economic Review, 2017-08-01.
