On November 19, William Cooper restated Cigar Coop's rule: a countdown cigar must already be a national release for at least 100 days, and July 4 is the cutoff. Cigar of the Year should go only to a cigar smokers could buy nationwide for that long. Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Dojo should adopt the same rule.
July 4 is a shelf date
Cooper's November 19 post calls the late arrivals Johnny Come Lately. Those releases often feel more like "first impressions" than cigars that have been for sale longer. He says it is unfair to compare "first-impression cigars" with cigars that have had "more extensive evaluation over the year."
The same post sets two clocks. A cigar released in the two years before July 4 of the current year can be eligible. The review must be published from November 1 of the prior year through October 31. He writes that the July wall "shows how the calendar year rule is completely broken by design."

The 2025 countdown criteria, dated December 9, 2025, fix the window. Eligible releases run from July 5, 2023, through July 4, 2025. The review had to appear on Cigar Coop from November 1, 2024, through October 31, 2025. July 4 to that October 31 deadline is 119 days, so a ship on the cutoff still clears 100 days.
That page also says the countdown cigar has to have been purchased, with an MSRP from the manufacturer. A re-smoke comes 30 to 45 days after the review. A sample can open a review. It cannot close the list.
Cooper would rather name the winner in April, which would leave 100 days after New Year's. He says that timing "simply won't work in the way our industry does things." The late cigar waits. Johnny Come Lately can become Johnny Can Wait and qualify the next year.
Four gates, one shelf clock
Cigar Coop counts days on a shelf. Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Dojo count the calendar year. These are the gates each publication printed.
| Publication | What gets in | Shelf clock | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cigar Coop, stated November 19, 2026 | National release. Review published from November 1 of the prior year through October 31. | At least 100 days on sale. July 4 cutoff. A late release waits until the next countdown. | 100-day rule |
| Cigar Coop 2025 countdown | Releases from July 5, 2023 through July 4, 2025, including new sizes. Reviews from November 1, 2024 through October 31, 2025. Minimum score of 90. | July 4 wall, to keep Johnny Come Lately off the list. Countdown ran December 12, 2025 to January 13, 2026. | 2025 criteria |
| Cigar Aficionado Top 25 | Review published that calendar year in the magazine or Cigar Insider. Cigars off the market, or too scarce to buy, come off. A tie favors the newer release. | No day count. The 2025 Cigar of the Year was scheduled for December 18. | Selection process |
| Cigar Dojo Top 20, 2025 | Sold in the USA and released in 2025. Votes from at least two panel members. | No day count. Number 1 was scheduled for January 16, 2026. | 2025 guidelines |
A review from that calendar year, or a release dated in that year, can still win while the box is new in the humidor. That scores the tasting. It does not score a shelf smokers have already used.
Eligibility is the first cut on our page on how to read a Top 25. The cut that belongs on Cigar of the Year is 100 days of nationwide sale.
The best case against this
Cigar Aficionado's selection process already removes cigars that are "no longer on the market or that are in such short supply they are unavailable." A July 4 wall would also block an October cigar that shops still have in December. A flagship that ships after July waits an extra season.
If the test is whether smokers can buy it on reveal day, the scarcity cut already does that job.
Put a national release on October 1. By December 18, 2025, the naming date in that process, it has been for sale 78 days and can still be on the counter. Cooper's rule does not throw that cigar out. It waits one countdown, and then it can win.

On December 19, Shanken News Daily reported that the magazine had unveiled its 2025 Cigar of the Year the day before, a perfecto rated 97 points at $75. The Best Cigars of 2025 names it: the Padrón 60th Anniversary Perfecto, made in Nicaragua, 6 1/2 by 56, medium-full, $75.
Padrón began shipping that perfecto on September 6, 2024, in small quantities, in boxes of 10. Jorge Padrón said, "We were not able to ship a lot of boxes." September 6, 2024 to December 18, 2025 is 468 days. Our premium cigars over $20 page lists that perfecto at $75.00, rated 4.85.
These sources do not name a 2025 winner that had been a national release for only a few weeks. The selection process prints no 100-day floor. Scarcity removes what you cannot buy. It does not remove what you have barely been able to buy.
A November ship still clears the calendar
On November 19, Cigar Aficionado reported that La Flor Dominicana began shipping three holiday lanceros the day before, November 18. Each is 7 1/2 by 38, with a pigtail cap, in a box of 20. They are rolled at Tabacalera La Flor S.A. in the Dominican Republic.
| Lancero | Wrapper | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Cameroon Cabinet | Cameroon wrapper over Dominican binder and filler | $14.40 |
| Double Ligero Natural | Ecuador Sumatra | $14.40 |
| Oscuro | Connecticut broadleaf | $14.90 |
They stay on sale until January 31, or until they sell out.
Dojo's 2025 guidelines set two tests for the Top 20: sold in the USA, and released in 2025. Apply those same two lines to 2026 and a November 18 ship still gets in. There is no count of days.
November 18 to January 16 is 59 days, and Dojo scheduled its 2025 Number 1 for January 16, 2026. One hundred days after November 18, 2026 is February 26, 2027. This sale window ends January 31, which is 74 days after the ship date.
Cooper's 100-day rule keeps a national release that ships after July 4 off that year's countdown. The cigar waits for the next list. These three have not been on sale for 100 days.
What would change this column
We would drop this demand if Cigar Aficionado or Cigar Dojo printed a 100-day national-release floor and used it on the next list. Until that line is in the rules, a December crown is a score for what the panel smoked.
Check the ship date before you buy the crowned cigar. The 2025 names and scores are in our 2025 Top 25 breakdown. What the cigar costs now is on the catalog price guide. Neither page says how long it sat on a shelf.
Sources
- A 100 Day Rule for Cigar of the Year Consideration, Cigar Coop, 2026-11-19.
- Criteria for the 2025 Cigar of the Year Countdown, Cigar Coop, 2025-12-09.
- Cigar Aficionado's Top 25 Selection Process, Cigar Aficionado, 2025-12-11.
- Cigar of the Year Guidelines 2025, Cigar Dojo, 2025-12-29.
- Cigar Aficionado To Publish Its Full Top 25 List, Shanken News Daily, 2025-12-19.
- The Best Cigars of 2025, Cigar Aficionado, 2026-01-05.
- Padrón Begins To Release 60th Anniversary Perfecto, Cigar Aficionado, 2024-09-06.
- A Trio Of La Flor Dominicana Lanceros For The Holidays, Cigar Aficionado, 2026-11-19.
