TravelHost's November 13 report finds Regal Princess's former Churchill's Cigar Lounge operating as a video game arcade. Leave it that way. A 3,560-passenger ship should not reserve an indoor room for a two-hour smoke when the shared outdoor smoking area already serves drinks.
A two-hour smoke doesn't earn an indoor room
Princess publishes a capacity of 3,560 passengers for Regal Princess. An indoor room on that ship has competing uses. Setting it aside for cigars means withholding it from an activity that cannot comfortably share the room during smoking hours.
We can get precious about an armchair once there's an ashtray beside it. Put a cigar on the table and suddenly ordinary hospitality becomes a tradition the operator is supposed to preserve. That is a fine way to furnish our own homes. It's a poor rule for allocating a passenger ship's space.
A dedicated room has to earn its place
A long seated cigar visit ties up the chair for its duration. That is precisely what makes a lounge attractive to its customer. For the operator, it also means the room must justify being dedicated to that use rather than remaining available for another activity.
A dedicated lounge should earn its footprint through the value passengers place on it, including their booking choices. Affection for the old room doesn't settle that calculation. Neither does our preference for cigars over arcade games.
Keep the arcade: cigar smoking already has a designated outdoor space. Restoring the lounge would reserve an additional indoor amenity for that same interest. A passenger who wants to play a game has bought a holiday too.
The deck already serves cigar passengers
Dan Kline describes a Deck 17 smoking area with attentive drink service. He also describes awkward access through the buffet and difficulty finding a useful elevator. Cigarette smokers share the space. Those details make a stronger case for improving the route than for reclaiming an indoor room.
A server bringing a drink to a cigar passenger is providing hospitality. A separate door and a room full of fellow enthusiasts would improve that passenger's evening, but the shared deck already supplies the essential permission and service. We should stop treating that as an insult.

The practical priorities are seats, usable tables, ashtrays and a route passengers can follow. Princess should direct its attention there. If someone cannot find the smoking area without a tour of the buffet, give them clear directions. Clear directions would address that complaint without taking back the indoor room.
Sharing also means accepting that another smoker's preferred tobacco may differ from ours. Cigar passengers can ask for decent facilities without demanding a private social category. Bring the same courtesy we expect in our lounge etiquette guide: leave room for the next person.
The best case for reopening Churchill's
The strongest objection is the evening itself. A comfortable indoor chair lets a conversation continue when rain or wind would end a deck visit. Enthusiasts can gather around a shared interest without waiting for suitable weather. A designated outdoor patch cannot reproduce that room simply by permitting the same cigar.
Kline and Dennis Post want the dedicated lounge experience restored. Their complaint deserves that interpretation. They are asking for a social venue, with shelter and continuity, rather than merely somewhere to dispose of ash. Our lounge comfort guide likewise treats the setting as part of the visit.
A reason to choose another ship
Other operators give that preference an explicit home. Norwegian Cruise Line's policy excludes cigarettes from its cigar lounges. That separation is a real amenity, and a passenger who values it has a sensible reason to choose a ship offering it.
The available sources establish neither cigar-passenger numbers nor comparative room revenue, and a firsthand visit cannot tell us what all cruisers will accept.
But a better evening for us still doesn't establish the best use of this room. A sheltered club can be valuable without being a necessary feature of every ship. Our answer is to choose and pay for that amenity where it exists. Princess should keep this room for arcade players and serve cigar passengers on the deck.
A cigar doesn't buy more space than a cigarette
The arrangements below separate an observed onboard alternative from published operator rules. They also show why passengers should check the particular ship before booking.
| Ship or operator | Observed arrangement or published rule | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Regal Princess | The visit report describes an outdoor area shared by cigar and cigarette smokers, with drink service. | TravelHost |
| Norwegian Cruise Line | Cigarettes are excluded from cigar lounges; Norwegian Sun has no cigar lounge and assigns cigars to outdoor areas. | Operator policy |
| Royal Caribbean | Smoking includes cigarettes and cigars; cigars are permitted in designated outdoor areas and cigar bars. | Operator policy |
A shared outdoor area is a deliberate service option, not a failure to recognize cigar tobacco. Princess should keep it that way. The distinction between a cigar and a cigarette doesn't entitle their owners to separate indoor real estate.
Princess should make the shared area pleasant enough to use for a seated visit. Cigar passengers should keep their cases and accessories off spare chairs. Cigarette smokers deserve the same courtesy. None of that requires restoring the old lounge or pretending the outdoor experience will satisfy every passenger.
Norwegian's policy also names a temporary bad-weather location by a towel station for Norwegian Sun. That detail answers a practical question. Princess should explain what happens when its outdoor area cannot be used, so cigar passengers can decide before booking whether that arrangement suits their holiday.
Leave Churchill's to the arcade players
If a dedicated indoor lounge is essential to your holiday, book a ship that offers one before packing the travel humidor. That preference belongs on your booking checklist. It doesn't give cigar passengers a claim on Churchill's once aboard.

Reopening advocates owe Princess sustained use and booking evidence that a cigar room would serve this ship better than the arcade. Affection for the old lounge isn't enough. Keep the arcade. The shared deck already serves cigar passengers their drinks; wanting a two-hour indoor smoke doesn't earn us another room.
Sources
Dates for undated operator pages are access dates.
- Princess Cruises Has a Cigar Lounge Problem, Cruisers Say, TravelHost, 2026-11-13
- Regal Princess ship specifications, Princess Cruises Japan, 2026-11-15
- What about smoking on the ship, Norwegian Cruise Line, 2026-11-15
- What is Royal Caribbean's smoking policy, Royal Caribbean, 2026-11-15
