Selected Tobacco's November 4 Petit Edition announcement puts two new sizes in a five-cigar set with a $164 suggested price. The maker should sell those new vitolas as singles from day one, instead of making a portfolio purchase the announced route to trying them.

A new size deserves its own sale

The company's release identifies the newcomers as Bandolero Premium Intrépidos and Nelson Nobles. They debut alongside Atabey Idolos, Byron Petit Poemas and Alfonso Añejo No. 1. That is an attractive arrangement for someone who wants a cross-section of the portfolio. It is a poor answer to someone who wants the new Bandolero.

A smoker choosing a shorter format has made a specific decision. Offering that cigar only through an assortment changes the transaction. The customer must choose companions for it, too, except the maker has already done the choosing.

A single cigar being offered across a shop counter toward an open hand.

We can be suckers for a handsome box. That doesn't make the box a good substitute for choosing our own cigar. The novelty belongs to the vitola, and access should follow that unit. A buyer interested in the new size should be able to pay its asking price and leave the rest behind.

Our short-cigar guide starts with the format a smoker wants. A launch should respect the same choice. Matching the customer's preferred size shouldn't require adopting the manufacturer's preferred assortment.

The checkout total is the price of admission

These offers show different ways to package a portfolio. Prices below are package totals, with the announced timing or listing terms attached. They establish the purchase on offer, rather than a ranking of the tobacco inside.

CollectionStated package priceContents and access termsSource
Selected Tobacco Petit Edition$164 suggestedFive cigars; two debut sizes; shipping scheduled for mid-NovemberCompany release, November 4
Selected Tobacco Robusto Edition$200 suggestedFive cigars; two previously unreleased sizes; original allocation tied to Madrid event retailersPCA release, October 22
Plasencia Holiday Collection$99.99 MSRPFive named toros from the portfolio; November shippingCompany release reproduced by Cigar Press

The retailer Mardo Cigars lists the Petit Edition at $164, with the quantity offered as a collector's set. For that listing, the relevant bill is the whole set. Dividing it into an average doesn't create a single-cigar purchase option.

The holiday collection illustrates why assortments deserve shelf space: a buyer may want variety as the product. Our objection begins when a new size supplies the reason to buy companions the customer didn't request. A sampler should win because someone wants the selection.

Our box-count analysis separates the package commitment from the per-cigar figure. Here the sharper distinction is between buying a cigar and buying permission to reach it. A lower average would leave that problem intact.

A hand holds two crossed cigars beside three cigars in a counter display.

The best case against this

The strongest defense is that an exclusive vitola gives a collector's set a reason to exist. A new format can turn an assortment of familiar names into a distinct release. Guaranteed assortment sales could also help a maker justify the handling and distribution of a small run.

The Robusto Edition announcement gives that defense a concrete setting. It commemorated the Madrid opening and introduced Bandolero Premium Atrevidos and Nelson Hidalgos. Its allocation was already sold out, according to the announcement. For an event souvenir, an unusual format is a more convincing extra than another piece of packaging.

Give singles their own allocation

That case deserves an answer about distribution. The releases disclose neither production costs nor a manufacturer rule forbidding retailers to split sets. We therefore can't price the operational burden or claim a universal ban on singles. We can reject the announced package as the default route to a new size.

A maker could supply a modest loose allocation alongside the collector presentation. Charge a single price that covers the extra handling. Keep the special case exclusive. Limit quantities when stock is short. Each approach preserves something collectors can buy without requiring every curious smoker to become a collector.

The defense fails when exclusivity itself becomes the main benefit: the set is desirable because the cigar cannot otherwise be bought. We would rather the maker earn that larger order through the assortment's appeal. If access is doing the selling, the sampler is the product being protected.

Launch the cigar and the collector's box separately

For Intrépidos and Nobles, the practical alternative is straightforward: let participating shops order stock intended for single sales at the same launch. Give those cigars their own stated prices. Put the gift presentation beside them and let the customer choose.

Supply can be finite without being bundled. A retailer can run out of a new cigar sold individually just as it can run out of a collector's set. Scarcity explains a limited allocation. It doesn't explain why the interested buyer must take an assortment home.

A hand offers a single unbanded cigar across a counter to another person.

We would also prefer this arrangement for a return visit. Someone who likes the debut cigar should have a clear way to request it again. Recommending another assortment answers a different desire. A launch built around the cigar ought to make the cigar easy to identify, order and buy again while stock lasts.

The sampler retains a proper job. It can introduce unfamiliar blends, make a gift or offer a ready-made comparison. Let the new size help tell that story. Stop making it the compulsory entrance ticket. The customer who chooses the box freely is the buyer the presentation actually serves.

Ask for the single

We would change our judgment of this launch when retailers have an announced, orderable single-cigar option alongside the set. A vague possibility that a shop might break one open is a weaker promise.

Ask for the new size by itself. If the answer is an assortment, leave it unless you want the whole selection. Makers should launch new vitolas as singles. A collector's box should have to sell the collection.

Sources