MBombay shipped two 6 x 54 pyramids on October 21, the Kesara Pyramid 2020 at $29.95 and the MQBA Mayura Pyramid 2019 at $39.95. Cigar Journal reported the release. Makers should stop selling years in a warehouse as proof of quality. Age is inventory, the blend is the craft, and no cigar should cost $40 because of a calendar.
The calendar is the only new variable
Both pyramids are 6 x 54 and both were rolled at Tabacos de Costa Rica. The report from halfwheel puts the Kesara at six years of post-roll age and the Mayura at seven, and says both began shipping on October 21. One year separates the cigars. Ten dollars separates them at the register.
MBombay's existing price list makes that jump harder to explain. Our price index catalogs four MBombay cigars from $7.49 to $11.50, and an MQBA Toro at $14.29. The new pyramids ask two to three times what the brand's current cigars fetch.
January is the tell. MBombay shipped the Mora in two sizes on January 15, both rolled in 2019, at $19.95 and $21.95. halfwheel reported the pair as aged releases. Same factory as the pyramids, same roll year as the Mayura, $18 to $20 less per cigar.
| Release | Post-roll age at release | Price per cigar | Pack | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MBombay Mora Robusto | About six years, rolled 2019 | $19.95 | Box of 10, 2,768 boxes | halfwheel |
| MBombay Mora Toro | About six years, rolled 2019 | $21.95 | Box of 10, 2,764 boxes | halfwheel |
| MBombay Kesara Pyramid 2020 | Six years | $29.95 | Box of 10, 834 boxes | halfwheel |
| MBombay MQBA Mayura Pyramid 2019 | Seven years | $39.95 | Box of 10, 826 boxes | halfwheel |
| Selected Tobacco Petit Edition | At least four years, some five | $32.80 | Five-cigar set, $164 | Cigar Journal |
| Selected Tobacco Robusto Edition Set | Four to five years | $40.00 | Five-cigar set, $200 | Cigar Journal |
Read the rows down. The roll year barely moves across four MBombay releases, and the top price nearly doubles between January and October. What changed was the size of the run, 2,768 boxes of Mora against 834 of Kesara, and a shape only one roller could make.
The catalog puts the ask in perspective too. Of the 3,248 cigars with a price in our catalog, 150 cost $30 or more and 75 cost $40 or more.
Mel Shaw, the founder, described the constraint himself: "We had one roller who could make this shape and one lot of tobacco to make it from. When the lot was gone, so was the run. Then we waited until the cigars were ready, not until the calendar said it was time." Then he put the year in the product name.
Age is a line item, not a signature
Selected Tobacco is the cleaner case, because it sells the years as the product. Its Petit Edition holds five cigars with at least four years of post-roll age, some at five. Each sits in its own aluminum tube inside a deep-wine case. The set is $164. The company's release gives the aging terms, which works out to $32.80 a cigar.
Its Robusto Edition Set carries four to five years, five cigars and a $200 suggested retail value, and the release says it sold out. Same house, same aging claim, forty dollars a cigar. The difference is a green case with a gold sleeve instead of a wine-colored one.

The trade already lives with the result. Cigar Insider's survey of 65 retailers covering 126 shops found 95.2 percent saw manufacturers' suggested prices rise in 2025, and 92.2 percent raised their own. Cigar Aficionado published the findings in January.
Colleen Murphy, who owns HogsHead Cigars & Fine Tobaccos in Hermann, Missouri, described the pattern from her counter. The cigars some brands are pushing, she said, are "the same damn sticks they've been selling for years."
Age is the cheapest story in a catalog. It needs no new leaf, no new roller and no new blend. It needs a date, and dates are free.
The best case against this
Take the objection at full strength, because it is not weak. Rest is real work, and cigars do not age at the same rate.
The leaves decide how much room a blend has to change. Cigar Journal's reference on aging potential says blends with more ligero in them age further.

The same reference sets the conditions. Aging stock wants 16 to 18°C at about 65 percent humidity, cooler and drier than the storage for everyday cigars.
Selected Tobacco makes the case in its own words. Post-roll aging, the company writes, is "an essential part of the work itself." It adds that "the final character of a cigar develops long after it leaves the rolling table."
Certain lines get five years, the release says, because each blend requires it. Then there is the bill. Thousands of cigars held for six years occupy climate-controlled space, carry insurance and tie up cash that cannot pay a salary this month.
A maker who spends that money is entitled to recover it. A smoker who wants a settled, rounded cigar is entitled to buy one.
What a cost of carry cannot explain
Grant the chemistry. Grant the bill. Neither turns a year into a verdict.
The same reference says a blend's aging potential depends on its leaves and on how the stock is kept. That is the whole argument: "six years" without a temperature and a humidity is a number without a method.
Didier Hoevenaghel wrote a book on the cigar from soil to soul, and the same reference quotes him. His judgment: "the aging is better in leaves (in piles and in bales) than in the cigars themselves."
If that holds, six years of post-roll rest is the second-best place to put the time. The premium is being charged for the second-best method.

If carrying cost set the price, the price would track it. MBombay's two pyramids differ by one year of age and $10 a cigar. The Mora, rolled the same year as the Mayura, sells for $19.95. Carry did not double between January and October.
These releases give a date and a price. None of them gives a tasting comparison across the years, which is the evidence that would settle the question.
If scarcity sets the price, say scarcity. One roller, one lot, 834 boxes is a genuine constraint, and charging for it is honest. The date is not the constraint.
What would change our mind
Three things, and any one of them would make an age claim testable:
- A blind panel scoring one blend at one, three and six years, with the peak named and the scores published.
- A price schedule where an aged version's premium equals a stated storage cost per stick, shown rather than implied.
- An age statement that gives the storage temperature and humidity, so a smoker can judge what happened in those years.
Until one of those exists, the roll year belongs in the product data, next to the size and the wrapper, not in the price. Our guide to buying legendary cigars without paying the legend tax makes the same case at the shelf.
At the counter, ask what the age did rather than how old the cigar is. Ask whether the blend is the one the brand sells cheaper, and what the extra years changed. If you want to run the comparison yourself, age a box at home and taste it against a fresh one.
A warehouse is not a blend. Price the leaf, the roller and the lot, and let the calendar stay on the box.
Sources
- MBombay Releases Kesara Pyramid 2020 and MQBA Mayura Pyramid 2019, Cigar Journal, 2026-11-02.
- MBombay Kesara Pyramid 2020 & MQBA Mayura Pyramid 2019 Showing Up on Shelves, halfwheel, 2026-10-29.
- MBombay's Mora Returns With a Pair of Aged Releases, halfwheel, 2026-01-12.
- Selected Tobacco Unveils Petit Edition, Cigar Journal, 2026-11-04.
- Selected Tobacco Introduces Robusto Edition Set, Cigar Journal, 2026-10-28.
- 2025 Cigar Insider Retailer Survey: Cigar Shops Report Sales Gains For 2025, Cigar Aficionado, 2026-01-27.
- What are the Influencing Factors of a Cigar's Aging Potential?, Cigar Journal, 2015-12-27.
- Price Index, Cigar Explorer, 2026-10-01.
