The Judge Grand Robusto is the only My Father cigar in our catalog rated 4.9, at $13.30. Four of the 41 are rated 4.8 or better, and two of those cost under $8. The list takes one cigar per line, ranked by rating, then price.
Price of the 12 ranked My Father cigars
The top rating, 4.90, is the My Father The Judge Grand Robusto at $13.30. The cheapest of the 12 is the My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro at $6.90. Ratings span only 0.30 of a point.
top rating (4.90) — $13.30the other 11 ranked cigars
- My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro$6.90
- My Father Flor de las Antillas Maduro Toro$7.50
- El Centurion H-2K-CT Toro Box Pressed$8.10
- My Father La Antiguedad Toro Gordo$8.80
- My Father No. 1$10.00
- My Father No. 4 Lancero$11.10
- My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed$11.40
- My Father La Opulencia Toro$11.80
- My Father No. 3$12.00
- My Father No. 5$12.90
- My Father Le Bijou 1922 100 Anos LE Corona Especial$13.00
- My Father The Judge Grand Robusto$13.30
How the list was built
We kept every catalog cigar filed under My Father with both a rating and a price. That is 41 cigars from $6.00 to $23.00, median $10.30.
| Pool | Count |
|---|---|
| Priced, rated My Father | 41 |
| Lines | 21 |
| Rated 4.9 | 1 |
| Rated 4.8 or better | 4 |
| Median price | $10.30 |
Rank is catalog rating, then cheaper price, one cigar per line. We read the line from the cigar's name. The 41 fall into 21 lines, so all 12 picks come from different lines and the list is not six Le Bijous. Every price is one cigar.
| Line | Cigars | Best rating | Cheapest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Le Bijou 1922 | 6 | 4.85 | $6.96 |
| La Opulencia | 5 | 4.75 | $7.10 |
| Connecticut | 3 | 4.5 | $6.00 |
| The Judge | 2 | 4.9 | $7.83 |
| Flor de las Antillas | 2 | 4.8 | $6.90 |
The other 16 lines hold 23 cigars, one or two each. No Connecticut made the 12. That line tops out at 4.5.
The catalog files El Centurion and one Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial under My Father, so they are in the 41. Fonseca by My Father is a separate catalog brand with 7 cigars, and it is not. The Nicaraguan list covers other Nicaraguan brands. The under-$10 list covers cheap cigars of any brand.
The 12 best My Father cigars, ranked
1. My Father The Judge Grand Robusto
- Rating: 4.9
- Price: $13.30
- Line: The Judge
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 5 x 60, Robusto, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father The Judge Grand Robusto is rated 4.9 at $13.30. It is the only 4.9 among the 41 and the dearest of the 12. Only two My Father cigars cost more, both limited editions rated 4.5.
Buy it if you want the top score in a fat 5 x 60. It is also #2 on the robusto list.
2. My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed
- Rating: 4.85
- Price: $11.40
- Line: Le Bijou 1922
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 6.13 x 52, Torpedo, Nicaragua wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed is rated 4.85 at $11.40. It sits 0.05 of a point under the Judge and costs $1.90 less. Le Bijou 1922 is the biggest line in the pool, with 6 cigars from $6.96 to $23.00.
Buy it if you want the best-rated Le Bijou. It is #1 on the box-pressed list, and the Le Bijou 1922 review covers the line.
3. My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro
- Rating: 4.8
- Price: $6.90
- Line: Flor de las Antillas
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 6 x 52, Toro, Nicaragua wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro is rated 4.8 at $6.90. It is the cheapest of the 12 and the third-best by rating. Only three of the 41 cost less, and none of them is rated above 4.5.
Buy it if you want the best score per dollar in the brand. The Flor de las Antillas Belicoso is also rated 4.8 and runs $0.60 more.
4. My Father La Opulencia Toro
- Rating: 4.75
- Price: $11.80
- Line: La Opulencia
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 6 x 54, Toro, Mexico wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father La Opulencia Toro is rated 4.75 at $11.80. It is the only 4.75 in the pool and the only Mexican wrapper on this list. La Opulencia has 5 cigars in the catalog, from $7.10 to $13.20, and this Toro is the best-rated.
Buy it if you want the Mexican wrapper. It runs $0.40 more than the Le Bijou at #2 and rates 0.10 lower, so the wrapper is the reason to pick it.
5. My Father No. 1
- Rating: 4.7
- Price: $10.00
- Line: No. 1
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 5.25 x 52, Robusto, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father No. 1 is rated 4.7 at $10.00. Six of the 41 are rated 4.7. Three made the list, and this is the cheapest of the three. The other three lost their place to a better-rated cigar in the same line.
Buy it if you want a 5.25 x 52 robusto from the numbered lines. It is the only No. 1 in the catalog.
6. My Father No. 4 Lancero
- Rating: 4.7
- Price: $11.10
- Line: No. 4
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 7.5 x 38, Lancero, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father No. 4 Lancero is rated 4.7 at $11.10. Its 38 ring is the thinnest on this list. The catalog files two other My Father lanceros as Panetela, so this is the only one it labels Lancero. It runs $1.10 more than the No. 1 for the same rating.
Buy it if you want a long, thin smoke. It is #5 on the lancero list.
7. My Father Le Bijou 1922 100 Anos LE Corona Especial
- Rating: 4.7
- Price: $13.00
- Line: Le Bijou 1922 100 Años
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 6.5 x 44, Corona, Nicaragua wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father Le Bijou 1922 100 Anos LE Corona Especial is rated 4.7 at $13.00. It is the second-dearest pick, $0.30 under the Judge. The catalog has two 100 Años cigars at the same $13.00. The other, a Corona Extra, is rated 4.5.
Buy it if you want the limited-edition Le Bijou in a 44-ring corona, the second-thinnest cigar here.
8. El Centurion H-2K-CT Toro Box Pressed
- Rating: 4.65
- Price: $8.10
- Line: El Centurion
- Strength: Medium-Full
- Size: 6 x 52, Toro, U.S.A. Conn. Habano wrapper, Nicaragua
The El Centurion H-2K-CT Toro Box Pressed is rated 4.65 at $8.10. The catalog files El Centurion under My Father, which is why it is here. It is the cheapest of the three 4.65s by $3.90 and the only U.S.A. Conn. Habano wrapper on the list.
Buy it if you want a box-pressed toro under $9. The other El Centurion in the catalog, the Corona Box Pressed, is rated 4.6.
9. My Father No. 3
- Rating: 4.65
- Price: $12.00
- Line: No. 3
- Strength: Medium
- Size: 6 x 49, Toro, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father No. 3 is rated 4.65 at $12.00. It is one of three Medium cigars on a list where eight are Medium-Full. The No. 3 Crema, the other cigar in the line, is rated 4.6.
Buy it if you want a numbered My Father below Medium-Full in a 6 x 49 toro.
10. My Father No. 5
- Rating: 4.65
- Price: $12.90
- Line: No. 5
- Strength: Medium
- Size: 6 x 56, Toro, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father No. 5 is rated 4.65 at $12.90. It matches the No. 3 on rating and strength and runs $0.90 more. The difference is the ring: 56 against 49.
Buy it if you want a Medium My Father with a thicker ring than the No. 3.
11. My Father Flor de las Antillas Maduro Toro
- Rating: 4.6
- Price: $7.50
- Line: Flor de las Antillas Maduro
- Strength: Full
- Size: 6 x 50, Toro, Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father Flor de las Antillas Maduro Toro is rated 4.6 at $7.50. It is the only Full cigar of the 12 and the second-cheapest. It runs $0.60 more than the Flor de las Antillas Toro at #3 and rates 0.20 lower.
Buy it if you want a Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro wrapper. It is the only one on this list.
12. My Father La Antiguedad Toro Gordo
- Rating: 4.6
- Price: $8.80
- Line: La Antiguedad
- Strength: Medium
- Size: 6 x 60, Gordo, Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua
The My Father La Antiguedad Toro Gordo is rated 4.6 at $8.80. It is the only La Antiguedad in the catalog. Three other lines also top out at 4.6 and missed the list on price: Cedros Deluxe, La Promesa and No. 2, at $10.10 to $11.50.
Buy it if you want a Medium 6 x 60 gordo. The Judge at #1 is the only other 60-ring pick.
What the extra money buys
| Cigar | Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Flor de las Antillas Toro | 4.8 | $6.90 |
| Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed | 4.85 | $11.40 |
| The Judge Grand Robusto | 4.9 | $13.30 |
| Toro Limited Edition 2010 | 4.5 | $20.00 |
| Le Bijou 1922 Limited Edition 2016 Toro | 4.5 | $23.00 |
The Judge is $6.40 more than the Flor de las Antillas Toro. That is 1.9 times the money for 0.10 of a rating point. The two dearest cigars in the 41 are limited editions rated 4.5, and neither made the list.
Interactive
Pick a My Father cigar
All 41 My Father cigars in our catalog, $6.00 to $23.00. Set a ceiling to find the highest-rated catalog reference within it. Prices may be historical; check current offers and stock.
Best My Father at or under $10.50: My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro, rated 4.80 at $6.90. 22 match.
The picker covers all 41 cigars, not only these 12. Set the most you will pay. It names the best-rated My Father at or under that price and counts how many you can afford.
What this list is not
It is not a factory tour or a tasting note. It does not rank Fonseca by My Father or the two Jaime Garcia Reserva Especial cigars the catalog files under their own brand. It skips any cigar without a catalog price or rating.
Which My Father cigar should I buy?
The Judge Grand Robusto if you want the 4.9. The Flor de las Antillas Toro if you want a 4.8 for $6.90. The Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed if you want the 4.85 in a torpedo.
Is Flor de las Antillas milder than The Judge?
Not by the catalog label. The Flor de las Antillas Toro and The Judge Grand Robusto are both Medium-Full. The Flor de las Antillas Belicoso is Medium, and the Flor de las Antillas Maduro Toro is Full. Strength on this page is the catalog label, not a tasting claim.
Does this list include Fonseca by My Father?
No. The catalog files those 7 cigars under a separate brand. The best-rated is the Fonseca by My Father Petit Corona, rated 4.65 at $7.00.
Are these box prices?
No. Every figure is the catalog price for one cigar. No box or retail price appears on this page.