Smoke Inn announced a second Black Works Studio Buzz Saw this month: a 5 1/4 x 54 box-pressed size at $120 for ten, sold only through the Florida retailer. Twelve months of exclusive sales is a fair return on a commission. A permanent wall around the blend is not.
The Buzz Saw came back instead of opening up
The first Buzz Saw arrived on September 23, 2024, as a 5 x 56 perfecto pulled out of Black Works Studio's 2021 Hive sampler. It was priced at $99.95 for a ten-count box and sold only by Smoke Inn, the first exclusive Oveja Negra gave that store.
The second is a different size of the same blend: Ecuadorian Maduro and Connecticut Shade over Nicaraguan binder and filler, rolled at Fabrica Oveja Negra in Estelí. Ten now cost $120, or $60 for five, which is $12 a stick. Cigar Coop's 2025 review put the first one at $9.99.
| Release | Size | Price | Where it is sold | First available | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Killer Bee Buzz Saw | 5 x 56 perfecto | $99.95 for ten | Smoke Inn only | September 23, 2024 | Cigar Coop |
| Killer Bee Buzz Saw 2.0 | 5 1/4 x 54 box-pressed | $120 for ten; $60 for five | Smoke Inn only | November 2026 | Cigar Coop |
| Shokai Bushido | Not announced | Not announced | Cigartopia attendees, then the Cigars Daily site | November 14, 2026 | The Cigar Guys |
| Smoke Inn Microblend series | Various | Various | Smoke Inn only, house blend | Ongoing | Smoke Inn |
The new size is not bigger. It runs a quarter inch longer and two ring gauges thinner than the perfecto it follows, and it is box-pressed besides, a shape our box-pressed rankings treat as a category of its own.
So the wall did not lift. It moved. The second release is another store-only size of a blend that already existed, sold at a higher price than the first.
Twelve months, then the same cigar anywhere
Here is the term sheet we want. Every store-exclusive commission carries a 12-month window. For the first year the shop is the only address in the country. After that, any retailer with an account can order the same cigar at the same wholesale price.
No one publishes standard exclusive terms, so 12 months is a number we are setting, not one we measured. The argument survives other numbers. What matters is that the window closes. Nothing here needs a regulator or a statute: a maker writes the window into the next commission and the thing is done.

What the shop keeps is real. It gets the launch, the press, the event, the first year of sales at full margin, and its name in the story of how the cigar came to exist. What it gives up is the veto over every other retailer.
Cigar Coop defines a shop exclusive as a cigar distributed to a single retailer, and since November 2023 it has required same-day press releases for them because the segment had become "extremely difficult to cover". One shop per blend is hard on the trade press. It is harder on the smoker in another state.
The rule covers national brands parked at one shop, not house blends. Smoke Inn's Microblend releases and its 25th Anniversary Raji were made for that store under its own name. Those can stay exclusive as long as the store lives, because the store is the brand.
The ticket, the wall and the leftover table
Dunbarton's Shokai Bushido makes the gate literal. The one-time Ecuadorian Sumatra batch debuts November 14 at Cigartopia in Phoenix, and the only way to buy one that day is a $130 general admission ticket.
After the event, leftovers go to the Cigars Daily website. Steve Saka's own estimate is that a few ten-count bundles might remain, and he has ZERO clue how many, if any, will remain.

Store exclusives like Dondurma, Khan 'Alam and Halligan let him share blends he likes without carrying more brands in the core portfolio, he told The Cigar Guys.
That is a brand-count problem, not a leaf shortage. The tobacco was bought, the blend was finished, the rollers were trained. The only thing between a smoker in Ohio and that cigar is who is allowed to order it.
Saka says this one is "one batch, one time." Fine. Then say the batch is finished and stop calling it a blend that exists. A cigar nobody can buy in year two is a museum piece with a price.
The best case against this
Put the objection at its strongest. A shop and a discount site selling the same box compete on price, and the shop usually loses. State tax decides much of it: the same cigar costs $9.50 on a Florida shelf and $13.59 in Utah before anyone adds a margin, per halfwheel's state table.
| State | Cigar tax | Price of a $9.50 cigar |
|---|---|---|
| Florida | 0 | $9.50 |
| Pennsylvania | 0 | $9.50 |
| California | 51.08% | $11.93 |
| New York | 75% | $13.06 |
| Utah | 86% | $13.59 |
So the exclusive is the one box on the shelf that the cheaper seller cannot list. Kill it after a year and the shop has paid for the launch of a cigar its low-tax competitor sells in year two. It also loses the reason to host the tasting, train the staff and give the blend a wall.
The tax gap is real, and it does not come from exclusives. It lands on every other box in the shop, every day, and a one-shop blend fixes none of it. A 12-month window does not hand the shelf to the biggest online sellers. The shelf was already shared.
The commission still gets paid, in three forms the shop can hold:
| What the shop keeps | Why it holds |
|---|---|
| A full year of exclusive sales at whatever margin the shop sets, with no identical box priced against it | The first year is the whole point of the term. |
| The launch, the tastings, the maker visit and the trade coverage that come with being first | Being first does not depend on being only. |
| A permanent credit in the cigar's history, which no competitor can copy | The story belongs to the shop, not the blend. |
At $12 a stick, the Buzz Saw 2.0 already prices above the $11.23 average cigar in our price index. Nobody is asking the shop to absorb a loss on it.
The rest is ownership of somebody else's brand. A shop that wants that can commission a house blend, which is a different product on a different deal, and Smoke Inn already sells several.
What would change our mind
Show us commissions that never recoup their first year, or shops that stopped commissioning once an exclusive lapsed, and 12 months becomes 24. Makers can print the end date beside the price on the release sheet; a term nobody publishes is a term nobody can meet.
Until then, ask. Ask the shop how long its exclusive runs. Ask the maker when the blend opens. We made the case last week for selling new sizes as singles; an exclusive is the same wall with a different lock.
Sources
- Smoke Inn Releases Black Works Studio Killer Bee Buzz Saw 2.0 | Cigar News, Cigar Coop, 2026-11-02
- Black Works Studio Killer Bee Buzz Saw Announced as Smoke Inn Exclusive | Cigar News, Cigar Coop, 2024-09-16
- Black Works Studio Killer Bee Buzz Saw | Agile Cigar Review, Cigar Coop, 2025-03-09
- Shokai Bushido: Steve Saka's One-Time Ecuadorian Sumatra Drop Debuts at Cigartopia 2026, The Cigar Guys, 2026-11-02
- Cigartopia 2026 - Legend of the Lost Leaf, Cigars Daily, 2026-11-10
- Smoke Inn Exclusive Cigars, Smoke Inn, 2026-11-10
- Cigar Taxes by State, halfwheel, 2026-11-10
- Qualifying Shop Exclusive Coverage Policies, Cigar Coop, 2023-11-01
