Flathead V660 Carb leads these twelve CAO catalog picks at 4.75. La Traviata Divino follows at 4.65 with a lower historical reference price. The useful comparison includes exact names and sizes: Vision editions, older anniversary names and several current format tables cannot safely be treated as interchangeable.

What this CAO ranking includes

The October 1, 2026 catalog snapshot has 44 exact CAO records. Forty-three have a rating and positive USD reference price and qualify for selection. The unpriced L’Anniversaire Cameroon Toro stays outside the ranking. These are retained records, without a claim of firsthand testing or current shop stock.

ScopeRetained catalog facts
All exact CAO records44
Eligible historical USD records43
Historical eligible price range$4.00–$16.00
Highest eligible catalog rating4.75
Source-qualified name groups20
Published shortlist12
Named and linked price provenanceMissing for all 44 records

Selection starts with rating descending, then reference price ascending. We take the first record in each defined name group before filling remaining places from the same order. The selected rows are sorted again and limited to twelve. A legacy group label organizes records without declaring equality with a current blend.

Historical prices of the 12 ranked CAO cigars

The highest retained rating is 4.75 for CAO Flathead V660 Carb at $8.39. These shortlisted references span $4.75 to $16.00; they are not current offers.

top retained rating (4.75) — $8.39the other 11 ranked picks

  1. C.A.O. Lx2 Bam$4.754.55
  2. CAO La Traviata Divino$4.954.65
  3. C.A.O. Brazilia Samba$6.254.55
  4. CAO Nicaragua Matagalpa$6.594.55
  5. C.A.O. Italia Ciao$6.694.60
  6. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire 1968-1998 Cameroon Robusto$6.904.60
  7. CAO Colombia Bogota$7.854.60
  8. CAO Gold Torpedo$7.894.55
  9. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso$8.104.65
  10. C.A.O. America Potomac$8.204.60
  11. CAO Flathead V660 Carb$8.394.75
  12. C.A.O. Vision Prana$16.004.60
Source: frontend/seo/catalog-seo.json, catalog generated 2026-10-01. The 12 shown come from 43 rated, positive-USD catalog references. Selection takes one leader per qualified catalog name group first, fills remaining places by rating descending then price ascending, and applies the final shortlist limit. Groups do not establish current manufacturer-line equivalence. Catalog generation is not a price observation date. Named linked price sources are unavailable; retained observation dates may be unknown. Ratings are catalog values, not firsthand testing. These historical catalog references do not establish current retailer prices or stock. The price axis starts at $0.

The chart uses these same twelve rows, with price bars starting at zero and catalog ratings printed alongside. Every amount is a historical USD reference. The observation date below is retained context, not a fresh quote from a named retailer.

Filter the twelve without changing their ranks

Use historical reference price and catalog strength to narrow the published shortlist. The picker keeps the original rank numbers and stays within these twelve records. It does not search all 43 eligible rows or supply current offers. Undisclosed remains an actual catalog label.

Interactive

Choose from the ranked CAO shortlist

Filter this bound ranking by historical reference price and catalog strength. Original ranks stay fixed; this does not search the full catalog or verify current offers.

12 of 12 ranked picks match.

  1. CAO Flathead V660 Carb4.75, USD 8.39Full
  2. CAO La Traviata Divino4.65, USD 4.95Medium-Full
  3. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso4.65, USD 8.10Full
  4. C.A.O. Italia Ciao4.60, USD 6.69Medium-Full
  5. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire 1968-1998 Cameroon Robusto4.60, USD 6.90Undisclosed
  6. CAO Colombia Bogota4.60, USD 7.85Medium
  7. C.A.O. America Potomac4.60, USD 8.20Medium-Full
  8. C.A.O. Vision Prana4.60, USD 16.00Undisclosed
  9. C.A.O. Lx2 Bam4.55, USD 4.75Medium-Full
  10. C.A.O. Brazilia Samba4.55, USD 6.25Undisclosed
  11. CAO Nicaragua Matagalpa4.55, USD 6.59Medium-Full
  12. CAO Gold Torpedo4.55, USD 7.89Mild-Medium

The CAO catalog contains the wider set. For what the descriptive labels can and cannot tell you, see the cigar strength guide.

The twelve ranked CAO records

The field lists retain catalog sizes, wrappers and strength labels. Seven historical size illustrations show selected records, with illustrative colors and silhouettes. They are not manufacturer photographs, confirmation of a historical recipe or a way to resolve a disputed current dimension.

1. CAO Flathead V660 Carb

  • CAO Flathead V660 Carb — Catalog rating: 4.75/5; Historical USD reference: $8.39; observation date 2026-05-19.
  • Retained size: 6 inches × 60 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: U.S.A. Conn. Broadleaf / Full.
Historical size illustration of CAO Flathead V660 Carb, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of V660 Carb, 6 × 60. Current classic Flathead dimensions agree. Wrapper color is illustrative; this does not establish V21 components or an unchanged historical lot.

The current Flathead table supports V660 Carb at 6 × 60. It is the only 4.75 entry in this eligible pool. Keep the classic Flathead name distinct from V21; sharing a 6 × 60 format does not make those component descriptions interchangeable.

2. CAO La Traviata Divino

  • CAO La Traviata Divino — Catalog rating: 4.65/5; Historical USD reference: $4.95; observation date 2026-05-19.
  • Retained size: 5 inches × 50 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Ecuador / Medium-Full.
Historical size illustration of CAO La Traviata Divino, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of La Traviata Divino, 5 × 50. Current manufacturer identity and recipe were not established. The Ecuador label and dimensions remain catalog fields; wrapper color is illustrative.

Divino has the lower historical reference among the two 4.65 entries here. The retained source check did not establish a current manufacturer recipe or exact current availability for La Traviata. Its Ecuador wrapper, size and strength above remain catalog fields; a missing candidate page does not establish discontinuation.

3. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso

  • C.A.O. L'Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso — Catalog rating: 4.65/5; Historical USD reference: $8.10; observation date 2026-05-19.
  • Retained size: 6 inches × 54 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Ecuador / Full.

The historical eXtreme record remains separate from current Extreme. CigarWorld’s current profile includes Honduras in the filler; the retained historical record lists Nicaragua. That source does not establish exact edition equivalence, so its current recipe cannot fill this older record’s specifications.

4. C.A.O. Italia Ciao

  • C.A.O. Italia Ciao — Catalog rating: 4.60/5; Historical USD reference: $6.69; observation date 2026-05-20.
  • Retained size: 5 inches × 56 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Honduras / Medium-Full.
Historical size illustration of C.A.O. Italia Ciao, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of Italia Ciao, 5 × 56. The current named format agrees. Wrapper color is illustrative; this match does not resolve the separate Novella identity and filler discrepancy.

The current Italia page supports Ciao’s 5 × 56 format. At 4.60, its reference price places it before the next four entries. The separate historical Novella is absent from that current size table and has a different retained filler description; Ciao’s compatibility does not resolve Novella.

Several similar names still need separate records

Historical nameCaptured source boundary
L’Anniversaire CameroonCompatible current Robusto/Belicoso dimensions do not establish exact old-edition equivalence
L’Anniversaire eXtremeCurrent Extreme includes Honduran filler; historical entries retain Nicaragua-only filler
The Sopranos Edition AssociateConsigliere mentions the heritage and has a compatible Associate, without explicit historical-edition equality
La Traviata, LX2, ConcertCurrent manufacturer recipes were not established in the retained source check
Cameroon NapoleonRetained 4.5 × 46 frontmark is absent from the current Cameroon table
Pilón RobustoRetained 5 × 50 is separate from current Robusto Extra 5 × 52

A current label may explain a family without identifying every older edition. Missing pages and absent frontmarks leave unknowns; they do not establish that a cigar was discontinued. For format terminology, our shapes guide separates commercial names from measurements.

5. C.A.O. L'Anniversaire 1968-1998 Cameroon Robusto

Historical size illustration of C.A.O. L'Anniversaire 1968-1998 Cameroon Robusto, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of L’Anniversaire Cameroon Robusto, 5 × 50. Current Cameroon dimensions are compatible, but exact anniversary-edition equivalence is unproved. Colors are illustrative; the historical name remains separate.

The current Cameroon profile has a compatible Robusto size and component table. It does not explicitly identify the old L’Anniversaire 1968–1998 edition as equivalent. Keep this historical anniversary record separate from the current-named Cameroon group, even where their dimensions agree.

6. CAO Colombia Bogota

  • CAO Colombia Bogota — Catalog rating: 4.60/5; Historical USD reference: $7.85; observation date 2026-05-20.
  • Retained size: 6 inches × 60 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Honduras / Medium.

The current Colombia table supports Bogota at 6 × 60. Compare it with V660 Carb if those retained dimensions matter to you, then read their separate catalog fields. The shared format does not imply matching wrappers, strength labels or an identical current cigar.

7. C.A.O. America Potomac

  • C.A.O. America Potomac — Catalog rating: 4.60/5; Historical USD reference: $8.20; observation date 2026-05-20.
  • Retained size: 5 inches × 56 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: U.S.A. / Medium-Full.
Historical size illustration of C.A.O. America Potomac, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of America Potomac, 5 × 56. The current named format agrees. Wrapper color is illustrative and the U.S.A. label is retained catalog wording, without proof of historical lot identity.

The current America profile supports Potomac at 5 × 56. Its U.S.A. wrapper field above remains the catalog’s wording. The matching named format does not prove which historical lot the record describes, and the retained reference price is not a present seller’s offer.

8. C.A.O. Vision Prana

  • C.A.O. Vision Prana — Catalog rating: 4.60/5; Historical USD reference: $16.00; observation date 2026-05-19.
  • Retained size: 6.25 inches × 52 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Dominican Republic / Undisclosed.
Historical size illustration of C.A.O. Vision Prana, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of Vision Prana, 6.25 × 52, retaining its Dominican wrapper field. Current Vision 2020 is a different 7 × 50/Cameroon description. Illustrative colors cannot resolve that identity gap.

The current Vision page describes a 2020 reimagining with Cameroon wrapper and Churchill 7 × 50. This Prana is retained as 6.25 × 52 with a Dominican wrapper. The current page also contradicts itself on binder and filler; neither paragraph resolves this historical identity.

Two current pages contradict themselves

Current official pageStory textProfile fields
VisionEcuadoran Sumatra binder; Nicaraguan fillerDominican binder; Nicaraguan, Honduran and Dominican filler
Flathead V21Connecticut Broadleaf binderHonduran Habano binder

The Vision page explicitly describes a 2020 reimagining. It cannot supply a recipe for historical Prana merely because both names contain Vision. V21 Carb’s 6 × 60 dimensions match its current table, but the binder contradiction remains. Choosing the paragraph that agrees with the catalog would hide the disagreement.

9. C.A.O. Lx2 Bam

  • C.A.O. Lx2 Bam — Catalog rating: 4.55/5; Historical USD reference: $4.75; observation date 2026-05-21.
  • Retained size: 4 inches × 45 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Nicaragua / Medium-Full.

Bam is the shortest retained format in this twelve. The source check did not establish current manufacturer specifications for LX2. Historical Bam and Toro catalog records also disagree on binder and filler. Keep Bam’s own fields instead of transferring another LX2 record’s recipe or inferring discontinuation from a missing candidate page.

10. C.A.O. Brazilia Samba

  • C.A.O. Brazilia Samba — Catalog rating: 4.55/5; Historical USD reference: $6.25; observation date 2026-05-25.
  • Retained size: 6.25 inches × 54 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Brazil / Undisclosed.

The current Brazilia table supports Samba’s 6.25 × 54 format. Its Undisclosed strength stays unknown. That size match does not resolve the separate Gol! record, whose current ring gauge and wrapper description conflict with the catalog. A family-level match cannot settle every frontmark.

Check these format conflicts before matching a current cigar

Retained catalog recordCaptured current-source difference
Flathead Sparkplug: 5.5 × 54Spark Plug: 4.5 × 50; matching Camshaft dimensions do not establish an alias
Bones Maltese Cross Maduro: 5.5 × 54Maltese Cross: 6 × 60
Brazilia Gol!: 5 × 54, Mata Fina wrapperGol!: 5 × 56, Arapiraca wrapper
Gold Torpedo: 6.5 × 52Current Torpedo: 6.25 × 52
Pilón Churchill: 7 × 48Current Churchill: 7 × 49
Italia Novella: 4.5 × 46, Honduras fillerCurrent Italia omits Novella and lists Italy, Nicaragua and Peru filler

These are identity or source conflicts, not instructions to overwrite old records. Our length and ring-gauge reference explains the measurements. It cannot decide whether similarly named editions are the same cigar.

11. CAO Nicaragua Matagalpa

  • CAO Nicaragua Matagalpa — Catalog rating: 4.55/5; Historical USD reference: $6.59; observation date 2026-05-21.
  • Retained size: 5.63 inches × 46 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Honduras / Medium-Full.

The current Nicaragua profile supports Matagalpa’s named format after rounding to 5.63 × 46. The retained Honduras wrapper field shows why a line named Nicaragua should not be used as a shortcut for every component’s origin. The size match does not establish historical blend continuity.

12. CAO Gold Torpedo

  • CAO Gold Torpedo — Catalog rating: 4.55/5; Historical USD reference: $7.89; observation date 2026-05-20.
  • Retained size: 6.5 inches × 52 ring gauge.
  • Catalog wrapper / strength: Ecuador / Mild-Medium.
Historical size illustration of CAO Gold Torpedo, with retained catalog dimensions and a ruler
Historical catalog size illustration of Gold Torpedo, 6.5 × 52. The current table instead says 6.25 × 52. Wrapper color is illustrative; this retained image does not settle the length disagreement.

The current Gold table lists Torpedo at 6.25 × 52, while this record is 6.5 × 52. The difference remains unresolved. Keep the historical size attached to this link; a present seller’s Gold Torpedo should be checked against its own stated measurements.

The unpriced record stays outside the ranking

Retained nameReference priceRanking treatment
C.A.O. L’Anniversaire 1968-1998 Cameroon ToroUnknown; currency unknownPreserved as an unranked name

That Toro accounts for the difference between 44 total records and 43 eligible USD references. No price is borrowed from the Robusto, Belicoso or a current Cameroon offering. Its historical identity remains qualified, like the other old anniversary records.

Pick the comparison before the price

For the highest retained rating, start with V660 Carb. For a lower historical reference at 4.65, compare La Traviata Divino while keeping its current-source gaps visible. If the exact current dimensions matter, look closely at the Gold Torpedo disagreement before matching the old record to a seller’s cigar.

ComparisonRecords to inspect
Highest retained ratingFlathead V660 Carb
Same 4.65 rating, different referencesLa Traviata Divino and L’Anniversaire eXtreme Belicoso
Shared 6 × 60 retained formatV660 Carb and Colombia Bogota
Edition or dimension uncertaintyVision Prana and Gold Torpedo

Use the exact name, format and source note together. A low reference without price provenance is a reason to compare, not proof of a bargain today. The box-pressed catalog picks offer a different cross-brand comparison without turning this CAO list into a market-wide ranking.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best CAO cigar in this ranking?

Flathead V660 Carb leads at 4.75 with an $8.39 historical USD reference observed on 2026-05-19. Its retained 6 × 60 dimensions agree with the current classic Flathead table. The price has no named linked provenance, and the ranking is based on catalog records rather than firsthand testing.

Why are there 44 CAO records but only 43 eligible prices?

The historical L’Anniversaire 1968–1998 Cameroon Toro has no positive USD reference price and its currency is unknown. It remains visible as a plain, unranked name. The other 43 records meet the rating-and-price eligibility rule; no amount is inferred from a similar current Cameroon cigar.

Is historical Vision Prana the same as Vision 2020?

That identity is not established. The retained Prana is 6.25 × 52 with a Dominican wrapper field. The current Vision page describes a 2020 reimagining with Cameroon wrapper and Churchill 7 × 50. Its binder and filler statements also contradict each other. Those current descriptions cannot be transferred to historical Prana.

Is Flathead V21 the same as classic V660 Carb?

They remain separate groups. The current V21 Carb and classic V660 Carb both have 6 × 60 dimensions, but that does not establish identical recipes. The V21 page itself gives Connecticut Broadleaf and Honduran Habano as conflicting binder descriptions. This shortlist’s leading record is classic V660 Carb, not V21.

Are these prices current CAO offers?

No. They are retained historical catalog references, with each observation date printed where available. All 44 CAO records lack named linked price provenance. The eligible pool spans $4.00–$16.00, but that range does not establish today’s stock, retailer quotes or what a seller will charge.